Wine Library › United States › Lake Erie › Lake Erie (Pennsylvania, New York, Ohio)
Lake Erie (Pennsylvania, New York, Ohio)
crisp white · appellation · United States · AVA
How it tastes, and why
- Body
- light (2 of 5). Light body; grapey, fruity
- Acidity
- medium (3 of 5). Moderate acidity
- Tannin
- little or none (1 of 5). White grape, so no meaningful tannin
- Sweetness
- medium sweet (3 of 5). Often made off-dry to sweet from native grapes
- Oak
- none (1 of 5). Unoaked
- Bubbles
- still (1 of 5). Made still
When to drink: young, up to 2 years after the vintage (Meant for drinking young)
In 2026 that is vintages from about 2024 on.
Serve at: about 8 °C (46 °F)
History
An AVA established in 1983 (T.D. ATF-156) along the south shore of Lake Erie, spanning New York, Pennsylvania and Ohio. The Pennsylvania Winery Association lists Concord, Riesling, Niagara, Catawba, Noiret and Vidal Blanc for its Pennsylvania side. Native American grapes do well in Pennsylvania's cold, and Penn State Extension says Concord is better suited to juice and jelly than to table wine. This entry models the Niagara and Catawba whites.
Facts
- Grapes: Niagara, Catawba
- Regions: Lake Erie, Pennsylvania
- Recognised: AVA 1983
- Classic pairings: ham, fruit salads, mild cheese, spicy takeaway dishes
Sources: ecfr.gov · pennsylvaniawine.com · extension.psu.edu
Goes with
- Firecracker shrimp — American · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · 100/100
- Tteokbokki — Korean · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · 95/100
- Sri Lankan devilled chicken — Sri Lankan · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · 95/100
- Red curry with beef — Thai · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · 95/100
- Chicken wings, mango habanero — American (weeknight) · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · 95/100
- Sri Lankan crab curry — Sri Lankan · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · 90/100
- Teriyaki salmon — Japanese · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · 90/100
- Hunan steamed fish head with chopped chilies — Chinese (Hunan) · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · 90/100
- Hawaiian pizza — American · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · 85/100
- Pizza with Calabrian chili and soppressata — Italian-American (pizza) · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · 85/100
- Sichuan hot pot — Chinese · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · 85/100
- Roasted sweet potatoes with rosemary — American (holiday) · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · 85/100
Dishes from our pairing reference, scored for Lake Erie (Pennsylvania, New York, Ohio) by Cellar Speaks’ pairing rules.
Vintages
How each year went, in words, as the sources rate it. Single bottles vary with the producer and how they were kept.
- 2025: Pennsylvania growers in a 2025 survey published by Penn State Extension reported excellent fruit quality after dry weather through ripening, but about 1,362 tons went unsold in a saturated market. No end-of-season Lehigh Valley report was found. Weather near Allentown, Apr–Oct: 1.1 °C warmer than the region's 1991–2020 average (growing degree days +11%); 684 mm of rain, drier than the region's 1991–2020 average (−11%); September rain −48%; 5 days of spring frost (7.1 on average); 4 days over 35 °C (3.2 on average). (NASA POWER)
- 2024: sources rate it excellent, too young. A hot, low-rain year with a very dry September and record heat gave consistent fruit. Big reds are expected to cellar for ten years or more. Weather near Allentown, Apr–Oct: 1.6 °C warmer than the region's 1991–2020 average (growing degree days +17%); 590 mm of rain, drier than the region's 1991–2020 average (−23%); September rain −72%; 1 day of spring frost (7.1 on average); 10 days over 35 °C (3.2 on average). (NASA POWER)
- 2023: sources rate it good, ready. A cool, wet season with wildfire smoke in the air gave lighter wines. Aromatic whites and early-drinking reds suit it best. Weather near Allentown, Apr–Oct: 0.6 °C warmer than the region's 1991–2020 average (growing degree days +4%); 794 mm of rain, close to the region's 1991–2020 average; September rain +36%; 4 days of spring frost (7.1 on average); 1 day over 35 °C (3.2 on average). (NASA POWER)
- 2022: sources rate it very good, ready. A dry season with very good ripeness in the southeast gave plush, structured reds and balanced whites. They are expected to drink well through about 2032. Weather near Allentown, Apr–Oct: 0.6 °C warmer than the region's 1991–2020 average (growing degree days +8%); 733 mm of rain, close to the region's 1991–2020 average; September rain −27%; 9 days of spring frost (7.1 on average); 8 days over 35 °C (3.2 on average). (NASA POWER)
- 2021: sources rate it mixed. Heavy September rain from Hurricane Ida after a hot, low-rainfall season made results depend on the producer. Whites picked before the storm and higher-elevation reds are the safer choices. Weather near Allentown, Apr–Oct: 0.9 °C warmer than the region's 1991–2020 average (growing degree days +9%); 919 mm of rain, wetter than the region's 1991–2020 average (+20%); September rain +80%; 5 days of spring frost (7.1 on average); 3 days over 35 °C (3.2 on average). (NASA POWER)
- 2020: sources rate it very good, approaching. May frosts cut the crop in a cool, wet year, but a dry September concentrated what remained. The wines suit cellaring. Weather near Allentown, Apr–Oct: Temperature close to the region's 1991–2020 average (growing degree days +2%); 818 mm of rain, close to the region's 1991–2020 average; September rain −23%; 10 days of spring frost (7.1 on average); no days over 35 °C (3.2 on average). (NASA POWER)
- 2019: sources rate it very good, ready. A long, warm and very dry season gave high yields without loss of quality. The wines are balanced and drinking well now. Weather near Allentown, Apr–Oct: 1.1 °C warmer than the region's 1991–2020 average (growing degree days +11%); 828 mm of rain, close to the region's 1991–2020 average; September rain −83%; 6 days of spring frost (7.1 on average); no days over 35 °C (3.2 on average). (NASA POWER)
- 2018: sources rate it difficult. A very wet year with heavy disease pressure and diluted fruit, best suited to sparkling wine and rosé. Weather near Allentown, Apr–Oct: 0.3 °C warmer than the region's 1991–2020 average (growing degree days +8%); 1,011 mm of rain, wetter than the region's 1991–2020 average (+32%); September rain +65%; 13 days of spring frost (7.1 on average); no days over 35 °C (3.2 on average). (NASA POWER)
- 2017: sources rate it excellent, at peak. A dry September in an otherwise average season gave elegant, European-leaning wines. The reds are at their peak. Weather near Allentown, Apr–Oct: 0.7 °C warmer than the region's 1991–2020 average (growing degree days +5%); 782 mm of rain, close to the region's 1991–2020 average; September rain −51%; 2 days of spring frost (7.1 on average); no days over 35 °C (3.2 on average). (NASA POWER)
- 2016: sources rate it good, ready. A warm year with normal rainfall gave soft, approachable wines. The reds are mature and best opened soon. Weather near Allentown, Apr–Oct: 0.9 °C warmer than the region's 1991–2020 average (growing degree days +11%); 582 mm of rain, drier than the region's 1991–2020 average (−24%); September rain −31%; 7 days of spring frost (7.1 on average); 5 days over 35 °C (3.2 on average). (NASA POWER)
- 2015: sources rate it mixed, past peak for most. Winter damage and late spring frosts devastated much of the crop in a cool, wet year. The wines that were made are high in acidity and are mostly past their best. Weather near Allentown, Apr–Oct: 0.7 °C warmer than the region's 1991–2020 average (growing degree days +8%); 658 mm of rain, drier than the region's 1991–2020 average (−14%); September rain −17%; 8 days of spring frost (7.1 on average); 1 day over 35 °C (3.2 on average). (NASA POWER)
Sources: extension.psu.edu · pennsylvania.guides.winefolly.com
Serving and keeping it
- Pennsylvania wine: the grapes
- Growers use three groups. Vinifera: Riesling, Grüner Veltliner, Chardonnay, Cabernet Franc, Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon. French-American hybrids: Chambourcin, Vidal Blanc and Seyval Blanc, and Cornell hybrids such as Noiret. Native grapes: Concord, Niagara and Catawba, mostly around Lake Erie. Wine Folly counts more than 50 varieties planted in the state.
Producers (11)
- Arundel Cellars
- Cellar '54
- Firelands Winery · since 1880
- Gideon Owen Wine Company · since 2020
- Johnson Estate · since 1961
- Klingshirn Winery · since 1935
- Mazza Vineyards · since 1972
- Penn Shore Vineyards
- Presque Isle Wine Cellars
- Quarry Hill Winery · since 2005
- Yori Wine Cellars · since 2003
On the label
- Grand River Valley AVA
- An American Viticultural Area in northeast Ohio (27 CFR 9.87, approved 1983) in Lake, Geauga and Ashtabula counties: the land inside the Lake Erie AVA that lies within 2 miles of the Grand River, west of Ohio Route 45 and within 14 miles of the lake shore. Wines registered in Ohio under the name are mostly vinifera (Riesling, Cabernet Franc, Chardonnay, Pinot Noir, Merlot) with Vidal and other hybrids, and include ice wines.
- Isle St. George AVA
- An American Viticultural Area that is the whole of North Bass Island in Lake Erie, Ottawa County, Ohio (27 CFR 9.51, approved 1982). The island lies inside the Lake Erie AVA. Heineman's Winery on neighbouring South Bass Island leases state-owned vineyard land on North Bass; the name rarely appears on labels registered in Ohio today.
- Lake Erie AVA
- An American Viticultural Area established in 1983 (27 CFR 9.83) along the south shore of Lake Erie in New York, Pennsylvania and Ohio. Native grapes such as Concord, Niagara and Catawba, with some hybrids and Riesling, dominate its Pennsylvania side.
1 wine of this style
- Markko Vineyard, Majestic Reserve — Lake Erie AVA, Conneaut, Ohio, United States