What wine goes with Steak Oscar (filet with crab, asparagus and bearnaise)?
Cuisine: American (steakhouse)
Full red fits best
Why a wine works with it. Such as Merlot or Cabernet Sauvignon. Fit: 85/100.
Why it fits
- Weight matches the dish
- Enough acidity to stand up to the dish
- Tannin cuts the richness
A little below room temperature: serve at about 17 °C (63 °F)
How we read the dish
- Weight
- Hearty (4 of 5)
- Richness
- Rich (4 of 5)
- Tang
- Some (3 of 5)
- Sweetness
- Not sweet (1 of 5)
- Chili heat
- None (1 of 5)
- Savoury depth
- Deep (4 of 5)
Mostly beef or lamb, grilled or seared, with a cream, butter or cheese sauce.
Styles sources pour with it
Opinions differ on this one. Beef under crab and butter sauce; a rich white or a soft red bridges both.
- Chardonnay (oaked) — Rich white · Weight matches the dish · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish. Against it: Red meat wants a red's grip · 60/100
- Pinot Noir — Light red · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish. Against it: Too light for the dish · 45/100
- Merlot — Full red · Weight matches the dish · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · Tannin cuts the richness · 85/100
- Champagne — Sparkling · Weight matches the dish · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish. Against it: Red meat wants a red's grip · 60/100
Scores are for the style in general, by Cellar Speaks' pairing rules. The list is what published pairing guides usually pour with this dish.
Serving temperature
| Wine | Serve at | How cold |
|---|---|---|
| Full red | 17 °C (63 °F) | A little below room temperature |
| Chardonnay (oaked) | 11 °C (52 °F) | Chilled |
| Pinot Noir | 15 °C (59 °F) | Slightly cool |
| Merlot | 17 °C (63 °F) | A little below room temperature |
| Champagne | 7 °C (45 °F) | Well chilled |
Reds go to the table a little below room temperature; whites, rosé and sparkling chilled, not so cold the aroma goes quiet. More on serving.
Styles sources usually avoid
A clash on these rules or in the guides: too much tannin, oak, weight or sweetness against what is on the plate.
Try it on the sample cellar · Wine Library
More American dishes
- Filet mignon with bearnaise — American (steakhouse)
- Surf and turf (filet and lobster tail) — American (steakhouse)
- Steak and eggs — American (brunch)
- Double cheeseburger with pickles and mustard — American (burger)
- Lamb burger with feta and mint yogurt — American (burger)
- Bacon cheeseburger — American
Dishes like this one
- Cote de boeuf with bearnaise — French
- Veal chop with morel cream sauce — French
- Cheesesteak with Whiz and onions — Pennsylvania
- Bistecca alla fiorentina — Italian
- Iskender kebab — Turkish
- Steak and cheese sub with mushrooms — Pennsylvania