Cellar Speaks Sign up free

All dishes › Pennsylvania and Mid-Atlantic

What wine goes with Shoofly pie?

Cuisine: Pennsylvania Dutch

Sweet or fortified fits best

Why a wine works with it. Such as Malmsey (Malvasia) Madeira or Tawny Port. Fit: 85/100.

Why it fits

Chilled: serve at about 10 °C (50 °F)

How we read the dish

Weight
Medium (3 of 5)
Richness
Medium (3 of 5)
Tang
None (1 of 5)
Sweetness
Dessert-sweet (5 of 5)
Chili heat
None (1 of 5)
Savoury depth
Little (1 of 5)

Mostly a dessert, roasted or baked, with no sauce to speak of.

Styles sources pour with it

Opinions differ on this one. A molasses crumb pie follows the nutty fortified wines given for pecan and other sugar pies.

Scores are for the style in general, by Cellar Speaks' pairing rules. The list is what published pairing guides usually pour with this dish.

Serving temperature

WineServe atHow cold
Sweet or fortified10 °C (50 °F)Chilled
Malmsey (Malvasia) Madeira14 °C (57 °F)Slightly cool
Tawny Port14 °C (57 °F)Slightly cool
Pedro Ximénez12 °C (54 °F)Slightly cool

Reds go to the table a little below room temperature; whites, rosé and sparkling chilled, not so cold the aroma goes quiet. More on serving.

Styles sources usually avoid

Sauvignon Blanc

A clash on these rules or in the guides: too much tannin, oak, weight or sweetness against what is on the plate.

Try it on the sample cellar · Wine Library

More Pennsylvania and Mid-Atlantic dishes

Dishes like this one