All dishes › Pennsylvania and Mid-Atlantic
What wine goes with Shoofly pie?
Cuisine: Pennsylvania Dutch
Sweet or fortified fits best
Why a wine works with it. Such as Malmsey (Malvasia) Madeira or Tawny Port. Fit: 85/100.
Why it fits
- Weight matches the dish
- At least as sweet as the dish
- A sweet wine for a sweet dish
Chilled: serve at about 10 °C (50 °F)
How we read the dish
- Weight
- Medium (3 of 5)
- Richness
- Medium (3 of 5)
- Tang
- None (1 of 5)
- Sweetness
- Dessert-sweet (5 of 5)
- Chili heat
- None (1 of 5)
- Savoury depth
- Little (1 of 5)
Mostly a dessert, roasted or baked, with no sauce to speak of.
Styles sources pour with it
Opinions differ on this one. A molasses crumb pie follows the nutty fortified wines given for pecan and other sugar pies.
- Malmsey (Malvasia) Madeira — Sweet or fortified · Weight matches the dish · At least as sweet as the dish · A sweet wine for a sweet dish · 85/100
- Tawny Port — Sweet or fortified · Weight matches the dish · A sweet wine for a sweet dish · 75/100
- Pedro Ximénez — Sweet or fortified · Rich enough for dessert · At least as sweet as the dish · A sweet wine for a sweet dish · 85/100
Scores are for the style in general, by Cellar Speaks' pairing rules. The list is what published pairing guides usually pour with this dish.
Serving temperature
| Wine | Serve at | How cold |
|---|---|---|
| Sweet or fortified | 10 °C (50 °F) | Chilled |
| Malmsey (Malvasia) Madeira | 14 °C (57 °F) | Slightly cool |
| Tawny Port | 14 °C (57 °F) | Slightly cool |
| Pedro Ximénez | 12 °C (54 °F) | Slightly cool |
Reds go to the table a little below room temperature; whites, rosé and sparkling chilled, not so cold the aroma goes quiet. More on serving.
Styles sources usually avoid
A clash on these rules or in the guides: too much tannin, oak, weight or sweetness against what is on the plate.
Try it on the sample cellar · Wine Library
More Pennsylvania and Mid-Atlantic dishes
- Pennsylvania Dutch apple dumplings — Pennsylvania Dutch
- Whoopie pie — Pennsylvania Dutch
- Chocolate-dipped pretzel rods — Pennsylvania
- Funnel cake — Pennsylvania
- Philly water ice (lemon) — Pennsylvania
- Apple butter glazed pork chops — Pennsylvania Dutch
Dishes like this one
- Mince pies — Dessert
- Sri Lankan wattalapam — Sri Lankan
- Bread pudding with caramel — Dessert
- Christmas cookies assortment — American (holiday)
- Cinnamon-sugar pecans — American (holiday)
- New Orleans bread pudding with whiskey sauce — Creole