Cellar Speaks: https://cellarspeaks.com/dish/philly-water-ice-lemon as Markdown (the HTML page there carries the same facts).

[All dishes](https://cellarspeaks.com/dishes) › [Pennsylvania and Mid-Atlantic](https://cellarspeaks.com/dishes#c-pennsylvania-and-mid-atlantic)

# What wine goes with Philly water ice (lemon)?

**Cuisine:** Pennsylvania

## Sweet or fortified fits best

Why a wine works with it. Such as **Moscato d'Asti** or **Asti**. Fit: 85/100.

### Why it fits

- Rich enough for dessert
- Enough acidity to stand up to the dish
- At least as sweet as the dish

Chilled: serve at about 10 °C (50 °F)

## How we read the dish

- **Weight**: Very light (1 of 5)
- **Richness**: Lean (1 of 5)
- **Tang**: Some (3 of 5)
- **Sweetness**: Dessert-sweet (5 of 5)
- **Chili heat**: None (1 of 5)
- **Savoury depth**: Little (1 of 5)

Mostly a dessert, raw or cured, with no sauce to speak of.

## Styles sources pour with it

Opinions differ on this one. A lemon ice is sweet and tart, so a slightly sweeter sparkling wine is reasoned, with the cold muting the wine.

- [Moscato d'Asti](https://cellarspeaks.com/library/style/moscato_dasti) — Sweet or fortified · Weight matches the dish · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · A sweet wine for a sweet dish · 85/100
- [Asti](https://cellarspeaks.com/library/style/asti_spumante) — Sweet or fortified · Weight matches the dish · Enough acidity to stand up to the dish · A sweet wine for a sweet dish · 85/100

Scores are for the style in general, by Cellar Speaks' pairing rules. The list is what published pairing guides usually pour with this dish.

## Serving temperature

| Wine | Serve at | How cold |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Sweet or fortified | 10 °C (50 °F) | Chilled |
| [Moscato d'Asti](https://cellarspeaks.com/library/style/moscato_dasti) | 6 °C (43 °F) | Well chilled |
| [Asti](https://cellarspeaks.com/library/style/asti_spumante) | 6 °C (43 °F) | Well chilled |

Reds go to the table a little below room temperature; whites, rosé and sparkling chilled, not so cold the aroma goes quiet. [More on serving](https://cellarspeaks.com/library/serving).

## Styles sources usually avoid

[Cabernet Sauvignon](https://cellarspeaks.com/library/style/cabernet_sauvignon)

A clash on these rules or in the guides: too much tannin, oak, weight or sweetness against what is on the plate.

[Try it on the sample cellar](https://cellarspeaks.com/demo/pair?dish=philly-water-ice-lemon) · [Wine Library](https://cellarspeaks.com/library)

## More Pennsylvania and Mid-Atlantic dishes

- [Pennsylvania Dutch apple dumplings](https://cellarspeaks.com/dish/pennsylvania-dutch-apple-dumplings) — Pennsylvania Dutch
- [Chocolate-dipped pretzel rods](https://cellarspeaks.com/dish/chocolate-dipped-pretzel-rods) — Pennsylvania
- [Funnel cake](https://cellarspeaks.com/dish/funnel-cake) — Pennsylvania
- [Italian cookie table (wedding cookies)](https://cellarspeaks.com/dish/italian-cookie-table-wedding-cookies) — Pennsylvania (Pittsburgh)
- [Shoofly pie](https://cellarspeaks.com/dish/shoofly-pie) — Pennsylvania Dutch
- [Paska (sweet Easter bread)](https://cellarspeaks.com/dish/paska-sweet-easter-bread) — Pennsylvania (Pittsburgh)

## Dishes like this one

- [Hawaiian shave ice](https://cellarspeaks.com/dish/hawaiian-shave-ice) — Hawaiian
- [Fruit plate](https://cellarspeaks.com/dish/fruit-plate) — American (brunch)
- [Mango lassi](https://cellarspeaks.com/dish/mango-lassi) — Indian (take-away)
- [Eton mess](https://cellarspeaks.com/dish/eton-mess) — British
- [Filipino halo-halo](https://cellarspeaks.com/dish/filipino-halo-halo) — Filipino
- [Rice cereal marshmallow treats](https://cellarspeaks.com/dish/rice-cereal-marshmallow-treats) — American
